Wed July 23, 2014
Common Ground Between Iraq's Rebels May Be Crumbling
Originally published on Wed July 23, 2014 9:36 pm
Abu Wissam speaks to us by phone from the northern Iraqi city of Mosul. He asks us to use his nickname to protect him, his family and his missing father before he recounts his father's kidnapping.
The men came on evening of July 3, just before Abu Wissam's family was preparing to break their day-long fast during the holy month of Ramadan.
"There were seven of them and before I knew it they were in our kitchen," he says.
Abu Wissam asked them who they were. They said they were from the Islamic State, and then they took his father, a retired general who served in Saddam Hussein's army. Abu Wissam hasn't heard from his father since.
The Islamist radicals that came to Abu Wissam's home still hold the large city of Mosul they took last month along with other parts of Iraq. But they had help, mainly from former members and sympathizers of Saddam Hussein's regime, which was toppled by the U.S. in 2003.
The Iraqi government, dominated by Shiite Muslims, by has been their common enemy of these Sunni Muslims.
But now there are signs that the uneasy alliance between the Baathists of the Saddam Hussein era and the Sunni extremists of the Islamic State is fraying and could fall apart.
Abu Wissam's father isn't the only officer who's been kidnapped. Dozens of others across the city, an apparent command center for the Islamic State, have also gone missing.
The Islamic State controls nearly three provinces of Iraq and pockets of other areas. Some Sunni Arab areas welcomed the fighters as liberators from a Shiite-led government seen as corrupts and sectarian. But some residents in Mosul now say the brutality of the group is beginning to show. Some Sunni towns have even risen up against the fighters with fatal consequences for the residents.
Abu Wissam, the man whose father is missing, thinks the group is trying to neutralize influential former officers before the men become a threat to the Islamic State. Baathists and the Islamic State are using each other, analysts say, for one goal: to take Baghdad and oust the Shiite-led government from power.
But the alliance is inherently unstable because their ideologies are polar opposite. Baathists are nationalists who believe in a strongman state much like the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein.
They were marginalized following the U.S.-led invasion and formed the original insurgency in Iraq to fight the U.S. presence and now the Iraqi government.
The Islamic State, meanwhile, is focused on taking over parts Iraq, Syria and perhaps other Arab states to re-create a medieval Islamic nation where it can implement its own harsh interpretation of Islamic law.
Abu Wissam isn't alone in his fear. We meet Abu Ahmed — whom we are also identifying by his nickname for his safety — in the Kurdish city of Erbil. He fled the city last week after his relative, once the head of Saddam's special forces, was kidnapped and Abu Ahmed received indirect threats.
Over cups of tea, late into the night he talks about the situation in Mosul.
"The Islamic State is completely in control," he says.
A few days ago, a new police force appeared in the streets, driving the Ford vehicles previously used by the Iraqi police. But the white cars have been rebranded with two red stripes and a circular black emblem with white letters declaring, "Islamic State, Islamic police."
The Islamic police wear long black shirts over baggy pants, similar to styles in South Asia. They break water pipes that people once enjoyed at cafes, send women home who they deem are dressed inappropriately, whip men who break their fast in the street during daylight.
An Islamic court has been formed as well. And there are the killings. Abu Ahmed and others estimates a few hundred people have been killed in Mosul.
Shiites have been killed on sight. Christians were forced to flee, as were other minorities, and Sunni Arabs who refuse to declare allegiance aren't spared either.
"They could only wear a kind mask for 20 days," Abu Ahmed says referring to the early days when the Islamic State fighters swept through Mosul last month, pulled down concrete blast walls, handing out cooking gas and vowing to protect the city. "Now their true faces are showing."
Abu Ahmed leans over and asks a friend for a cigarette. He jokes: "I can't smoke in Mosul, it's illegal now."
His relative was also a senior officer in Saddam's army. He was taken on the same day and in the same way as Abu Wissam's father.
"This was planned. These generals are symbols in Mosul," Abu Ahmed says. "They can make the city rise and they can prepare a comprehensive army in a month."
This, he says, is why they were taken.
"When they took my relative they said it was for consultations, but in reality he is a threat to them," Abu Ahmed says.
Both Abu Ahmed and Abu Wissam believe their relatives are alive, at least for now. Killing them would cause an uproar, they say.
And yet despite the kidnappings, the killings and the merciless interpretation of Islamic law, the city of Mosul still hasn't risen up against the fighters and the tentative alliances are still intact.
This month, Izzat al-Douri, a prominent deputy to Saddam Hussein, and the leader of a Sufi-inspired fighting group, released an audio recording. In it he urged unity for the fight for Baghdad and called fighters of the Islamic State and al-Qaida heroes.
"Our division is the greater enemy," he said in the recording, which appeared on a Baathist website, but couldn't be independently verified. "We have to postpone all differences regardless of their magnitude."
Abu Ahmed echoed al-Douri's words. The alliance continues, he says, because there is a more important goal right now — ousting the government led by Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.
"If they divide and fight each other the Iraqi army will come with a vengeance to kill indiscriminately," he says.
Abu Ahmed says the world needs to stop supporting Maliki, and back the Baathists against the much more brutal Islamic State. It's a choice the world might not like, he says.
But "if you face death or a fever," he says, citing an old Arabic proverb, "you're smart to choose the fever."
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
The group that took over the Iraqi city of Mosul last month which calls itself the Islamic State had some help. The Sunni radicals were supported by remnants of Saddam Hussein's old Baathist Party regime and the former military. The groups were united by their hatred of the Shiite dominated Iraqi government, but the alliance is fragile. NPR's Leila Fadel reports that some of the Baathists have gone missing.
LEILA FADEL, BYLINE: We reach Abu Wissam by phone in the city of Mosul - the apparent command center of the Islamic State here in Iraq. He asks us to use his nickname to protect himself before he recounts his father's kidnapping this month, the month of Ramadan when Muslims fast from sunup to sundown.
ABU WISSAM: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: He says, they came on July 3, just as we were about to break our fast. There were seven of them, and before I knew it, they were in our kitchen. Where's your father, they asked me. He's here, Abu Wissam responded. Who are you? Why are you carrying guns inside our home? They responded, we are the Islamic State.
WISSAM: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: Abu Wissam's father, an elderly man and a former general in Saddam's army, went with the men. We just have a few questions, they said, don't worry. But Abu Wissam hasn't heard from his father since. He thinks they are trying to neutralize influential former officers before the men become a threat to the so-called Islamic State. Baathist and the Islamic State are using each other, analyst say, for one goal - to take Baghdad and oust the Shia-led government from power. But their ideologies are polar opposite. Baathists are nationalists who believe in a strong man state. They were marginalized following the U.S.-led invasion and formed the original insurgency in Iraq to fight the occupation. But the Islamic State is trying to redraw the Middle East and enforce their brutal interpretation of Islamic law. Abu Wissam is not the only one that's worried.
ABU AHMED: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: Abu Ahmed meets us in the Kurdish city of Erbil. He fled Mosul last week and his relatives also taken by the Islamic State. He talks about the situation in Mosul.
AHMED: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: He says, the Islamic State is in complete control. Last week, a new police force appeared in the streets, driving the Ford vehicles once used by the Iraqi police. But the white cars are rebranded with two red stripes and a circular black emblem with white letters declaring Islamic State, Islamic police. The men were black long shirts over baggy pants in the style of South Asia. They break writer pipes that people once enjoyed at cafes. They send women home who they deemed are dressed inappropriately. They whip men who break their fast in the street during daylight. And an Islamic court has been formed as well. Meanwhile, there are little to no services. He leans over and asks for a cigarette from my colleague and jokes I can't smoking in Mosul anymore. It's against the law. His relative was also a general in Saddam's army. He says he was taken in the same way and on the same day as
Abu Wissam's father.
AHMED: (Foreign language spoken.
FADEL: These generals are symbols in Mosul, he says. They can make this city rise, and they can prepare a comprehensive army in a month. When they took my relative, they said it was for consultations, but in reality, he is a threat to them.
AHMED: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: Abu Ahmed says his relative is still alive - not like hundreds of others who've been killed. Shiite Iraqis are automatically slain, and journalists have been killed, too. I ask why this city doesn't arise up against the fighters.
AHMED: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: Because, he says, they have a more important goal. If they divide and fight each other, the Iraqi army will come with a vengeance to kill indiscriminately. So the people of Mosul back the Islamic State despite all the drawbacks because they have a higher target, the government led by Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki and the entire political process.
AHMED: (Foreign language spoken).
FADEL: He says the world needs to stop supporting Maliki and then back the Baathists against the much more brutal Islamic State. It's a choice the world might not like but, there's an old Arabic proverb - if you face death or a fever, you're smart to choose the fever. Leila Fadel, NPR News, Erbil. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.